BetaNo feature or time limits right now.About the beta

Any OS

Blog ·

How Does Any OS Graphics Performance Compare to Native?

How big is the gap between 3DMark in a Windows VM on a Mac and native? We measured 8 benchmarks at 4K full screen on the same Mac Studio.

How Much Graphics Performance Does a Windows VM on a Mac Deliver?

How different is it to run games in a Windows VM on a Mac versus running them natively? While building Any OS, this is a question we kept wanting to answer ourselves.

In Any OS, the DirectX 12 and Vulkan calls sent by the guest Windows are handled by the host Mac through Metal. A macOS app calls Metal directly, so the VM path adds one extra step. We measured how much that step costs with 3DMark on the same Mac.

Two questions we wanted to answer

  1. 1.What percentage of native does Any OS graphics performance reach?
  2. 2.Do DirectX 12 benchmarks run without errors in a Windows VM on a Mac?

The short version

  • In 4 of the 5 benchmarks we compared, the Any OS VM reached about 90% of native or more.
  • Solar Bay was 129.9% and Steel Nomad Light was 136.3%, both faster than Mac native.
  • Solar Bay Extreme at 89.3% and Wild Life Extreme at 92.7% came very close to native.
  • The Any OS VM on a Mac performs between the NVIDIA RTX 4060 Ti and 4070, the level of a mid-range graphics card.
  • The heaviest benchmark, Steel Nomad, reached 76.9% (DirectX 12).
  • All 5 DirectX 12 benchmarks (Steel Nomad, Steel Nomad Light, Wild Life Extreme, Speed Way, Port Royal) ran in the VM without errors and produced scores.

Test Hardware

ItemMac nativeAny OS VMWindows PC (RTX 4090)
ChipApple M5 MaxApple M5 Max (host)Intel Core i9-13900HX
vCPUN/A8N/A
GPU40-core GPUVirtual GPU (handled by the Mac GPU through Metal)RTX 4090 Laptop GPU
Memory128 GB16 GB32 GB
OSmacOS 27.2Windows 11 ARM64Windows 11 x64
3DMark app version1.1.3502.32.89192.32.8919
Graphics APIMetalDirectX 12, VulkanDirectX 12, Vulkan
Display4K full screen4K full screen (guest 3840×2160)Full screen

Mac native and the Any OS VM were measured on the same Mac Studio.

Test Conditions

ItemMac nativeAny OS VMWindows PC (RTX 4090)
PresetDefaultDefaultDefault
DisplayFull screenFull screenFull screen
API selectionNone (Metal)2 Steel Nomad benchmarks2 Steel Nomad benchmarks
  • The benchmarks that let you pick an API are Steel Nomad and Steel Nomad Light, and we measured each with DirectX 12 and with Vulkan.
  • VM ÷ native is the VM score divided by the Mac native score.

Which Benchmarks We Ran

BenchmarkFocusRender resolutionRay tracingAPI on Windows
Solar Bay ExtremeHeavy ray tracing for mobile devices2560×1440YesVulkan
Wild Life ExtremeShared across Windows, Mac, and mobile devices3840×2160NoAutomatic per device
Steel NomadFor high-performance gaming PCs3840×2160NoDirectX 12, Vulkan
Steel Nomad LightFor lighter PCs2560×1440NoDirectX 12, Vulkan
Solar BayVulkan 1.1, ray tracing for Metal2560×1440YesVulkan
Speed WayDirectX 12 Ultimate for gaming PCs2560×1440YesDirectX 12
Port RoyalReal-time ray tracing2560×1440YesDirectX 12
Wild LifeFor mobile devices2560×1440NoNo selection
  • Wild Life Extreme runs with DirectX 12 on ARM-based Windows and with Vulkan on x64 Windows.
  • Solar Bay Extreme has more detailed scenes and a heavier ray tracing load than Solar Bay.
  • Speed Way, Port Royal, and Wild Life are not in 3DMark for macOS, so we did not compare them with native.

Are 3DMark for Mac and 3DMark for Windows the Same Program?

The two apps share a name but are different programs. The app versions differ, and for all five benchmarks available on both Mac and Windows, the workload versions differ too. That makes it hard to compare the scores from the two apps directly.

Version3DMark for macOS3DMark for Windows
App1.1.3502.32.8919
Solar Bay workload1.0.17.41.0.18.1
Solar Bay Extreme workload1.0.3.61.0.6.2
Steel Nomad Light workload1.0.6.21.0.5.1
Steel Nomad workload1.0.6.21.0.5.1
Wild Life Extreme workload1.1.14.31.1.14.1

On Windows, the Steel Nomad family has a separate workload for each API.

BenchmarkmacOS workloadWindows workload
Steel Nomad LightSteelNomadGt1LTSteelNomadGt1DXLT, SteelNomadGt1VKLT
Steel NomadSteelNomadGt1PSteelNomadGt1DX, SteelNomadGt1VK
  • Solar Bay, Solar Bay Extreme, and Wild Life Extreme have the same workload names in both apps.
  • For the Solar Bay family, the ray tracing method is inline on both Mac native and the Any OS VM, and pipeline on the Windows PC.

Results at a Glance

  • Green bold text marks the higher score between Mac native and the Any OS VM. The Windows PC (RTX 4090) column is for reference only, so it is not marked.
  • In the VM ÷ native column, the two benchmarks with similar workloads are shown in green and Steel Nomad, with the largest gap, in orange. Values above 100% are not colored.
BenchmarkVM APIMac native (Metal)Any OS VMVM ÷ nativeWindows PC (RTX 4090)
Solar Bay ExtremeVulkan12,079 pts / 84.47 FPS10,788 pts / 75.45 FPS89.3%17,540 pts / 122.66 FPS
Wild Life ExtremeDirectX 1225,097 pts / 150.29 FPS23,263 pts / 139.30 FPS92.7%35,225 pts / 210.93 FPS (Vulkan)
Steel NomadDirectX 124,548 pts / 45.48 FPS3,499 pts / 34.99 FPS76.9%4,580 pts / 45.80 FPS
Steel NomadVulkan4,548 pts / 45.48 FPS3,000 pts / 30.01 FPS66.0%4,589 pts / 45.89 FPS
Steel Nomad LightDirectX 129,488 pts / 70.28 FPS12,933 pts / 95.81 FPS136.3%20,881 pts / 154.68 FPS
Steel Nomad LightVulkan9,488 pts / 70.28 FPS13,924 pts / 103.14 FPS146.8%20,128 pts / 149.10 FPS
Solar BayVulkan39,244 pts / 149.22 FPS50,963 pts / 193.78 FPS129.9%85,342 pts / 324.50 FPS
Speed WayDirectX 12No macOS version3,361 pts / 33.61 FPS-5,203 pts / 52.03 FPS
Port RoyalDirectX 12No macOS version8,463 pts / 39.18 FPS-9,111 pts / 42.19 FPS
Wild LifeNo selectionNo macOS version47,718 pts / 285.74 FPS-82,394 pts / 493.38 FPS

The Two Benchmarks with Similar Workloads Reach About 90%

Solar Bay Extreme

ItemMac nativeAny OS VMWindows PC (RTX 4090)
APIMetalVulkanVulkan
Score / average FPS12,079 pts / 84.47 FPS10,788 pts / 75.45 FPS17,540 pts / 122.66 FPS
VM ÷ native-89.3%-
Solar Bay Extreme result screen in 3DMark for macOS
Mac native (Metal): 12,079 pts, average 84.47 FPS
Solar Bay Extreme result screen in 3DMark for Windows inside the Any OS VM
Any OS VM (Vulkan): 10,788 pts, average 75.45 FPS
Solar Bay Extreme result screen in 3DMark on the Windows PC
Windows PC (RTX 4090, Vulkan): 17,540 pts, average 122.66 FPS

Wild Life Extreme

ItemMac nativeAny OS VMWindows PC (RTX 4090)
APIMetalDirectX 12Vulkan
Score / average FPS25,097 pts / 150.29 FPS23,263 pts / 139.30 FPS35,225 pts / 210.93 FPS
VM ÷ native-92.7%-
  • In the VM, Vulkan could only be selected in a Custom run, which produces no score, and it averaged 161.93 FPS.
Wild Life Extreme result screen in 3DMark for macOS
Mac native (Metal): 25,097 pts, average 150.29 FPS
Wild Life Extreme result screen in 3DMark for Windows inside the Any OS VM
Any OS VM (DirectX 12): 23,263 pts, average 139.30 FPS
Wild Life Extreme result screen in 3DMark on the Windows PC
Windows PC (RTX 4090, Vulkan): 35,225 pts, average 210.93 FPS

Why we used these two benchmarks as the reference

These two benchmarks have the same workload names and render resolutions in the Mac and Windows apps. For Wild Life Extreme, the workload versions differ only in the last digit. They are the pairs that let us compare the VM and native under the most similar conditions, so we used them as the reference.

Converting average FPS to frame time, Solar Bay Extreme goes from 11.84 ms to 13.25 ms and Wild Life Extreme goes from 6.65 ms to 7.18 ms. That is 1.4 ms and 0.5 ms more per frame. The OS, API, app build, and display path all changed together, so this is not the virtualization cost in isolation.

The Heaviest Benchmark, Steel Nomad, Reaches 76.9%

APIMac nativeAny OS VMWindows PC (RTX 4090)
DirectX 124,548 pts / 45.48 FPS (Metal)3,499 pts / 34.99 FPS4,580 pts / 45.80 FPS
Vulkan4,548 pts / 45.48 FPS (Metal)3,000 pts / 30.01 FPS4,589 pts / 45.89 FPS
VM ÷ native-76.9% (DirectX 12), 66.0% (Vulkan)-
Steel Nomad result screen in 3DMark for macOS
Mac native (Metal): 4,548 pts, average 45.48 FPS
Steel Nomad DirectX 12 result screen in 3DMark for Windows inside the Any OS VM
Any OS VM (DirectX 12): 3,499 pts, average 34.99 FPS
Steel Nomad Vulkan result screen in 3DMark for Windows inside the Any OS VM
Any OS VM (Vulkan): 3,000 pts, average 30.01 FPS
Steel Nomad DirectX 12 result screen in 3DMark on the Windows PC
Windows PC (RTX 4090, DirectX 12): 4,580 pts, average 45.80 FPS

This is the heaviest benchmark, rendering at 4K. With DirectX 12, a frame goes from 21.99 ms to 28.58 ms, about 6.6 ms more. Steel Nomad has different workload names and versions in the two apps, so this measurement could not tell how much of the 76.9% is attributable to Any OS.

In the VM, DirectX 12 scored 16.6% higher than Vulkan. That difference alone is too little to say which API is better.

Comparison with NVIDIA Graphics Cards

We compared the Steel Nomad score with the median score of each NVIDIA graphics card. The Any OS VM scored 3,499 pts (DirectX 12).

GPUSteel Nomad medianRelative to the Any OS VM (3,499 pts)
GeForce RTX 50705,340 ptsHigher than the VM
GeForce RTX 40703,845 ptsHigher than the VM
GeForce RTX 5060 Ti3,592 ptsSimilar to the VM
GeForce RTX 3070 Ti3,501 ptsSimilar to the VM
GeForce RTX 4060 Ti 8 GB2,907 ptsLower than the VM

The Any OS VM on the M5 Max scored close to the RTX 3070 Ti and 5060 Ti. It lands between the RTX 4060 Ti and 4070, the performance level of an NVIDIA mid-range graphics card.

Comparison with Other VM Apps

We summarized the public information on other VM apps that run Windows on a Mac, using the same criteria.

VM appDirectX 12 benchmark scores published
Any OSYes (this post)
Parallels DesktopNot found
VMware FusionNot found
UTMNot found

Any OS ran 5 DirectX 12 benchmarks and produced scores, and in Solar Bay and Steel Nomad Light it scored higher than Mac native. We could not find DirectX 12 benchmark scores under the same conditions published for the other VM apps.

Solar Bay and Steel Nomad Light, Where the VM Scored Higher

Solar Bay

ItemMac nativeAny OS VMWindows PC (RTX 4090)
APIMetalVulkanVulkan
Score / average FPS39,244 pts / 149.22 FPS50,963 pts / 193.78 FPS85,342 pts / 324.50 FPS
VM ÷ native-129.9%-
Solar Bay result screen in 3DMark for macOS
Mac native (Metal): 39,244 pts, average 149.22 FPS
Solar Bay result screen in 3DMark for Windows inside the Any OS VM
Any OS VM (Vulkan): 50,963 pts, average 193.78 FPS
Solar Bay result screen in 3DMark on the Windows PC
Windows PC (RTX 4090, Vulkan): 85,342 pts, average 324.50 FPS

Steel Nomad Light

APIMac nativeAny OS VMWindows PC (RTX 4090)
DirectX 129,488 pts / 70.28 FPS (Metal)12,933 pts / 95.81 FPS20,881 pts / 154.68 FPS
Vulkan9,488 pts / 70.28 FPS (Metal)13,924 pts / 103.14 FPS20,128 pts / 149.10 FPS
VM ÷ native-136.3% (DirectX 12), 146.8% (Vulkan)-
Steel Nomad Light result screen in 3DMark for macOS
Mac native (Metal): 9,488 pts, average 70.28 FPS
Steel Nomad Light DirectX 12 result screen in 3DMark for Windows inside the Any OS VM
Any OS VM (DirectX 12): 12,933 pts, average 95.81 FPS
Steel Nomad Light Vulkan result screen in 3DMark for Windows inside the Any OS VM
Any OS VM (Vulkan): 13,924 pts, average 103.14 FPS
Steel Nomad Light DirectX 12 result screen in 3DMark on the Windows PC
Windows PC (RTX 4090, DirectX 12): 20,881 pts, average 154.68 FPS

Why did the VM score higher?

In these two benchmarks, the Any OS VM scored higher than Mac native. This measurement alone could not pin down the cause. Here we separate what we confirmed from possible explanations.

  • Confirmed: the two apps differ in both app version and workload version.
  • Confirmed: within the same app, the ratio of the lighter benchmark score to the heavier benchmark score is similar for the two machines that use the Windows app, and only the macOS app differs (see the table below).
  • Possible: the platform-specific implementation and optimization of 3DMark for macOS and for Windows may differ.
  • Possible: Metal, DirectX 12, and Vulkan follow different graphics API paths.
  • Possible: the efficiency of the path handled by the host Mac GPU may differ.
Score ratioMac nativeAny OS VMWindows PC (RTX 4090)
Steel Nomad Light ÷ Steel Nomad2.093.70 (DirectX 12), 4.64 (Vulkan)4.56 (DirectX 12), 4.39 (Vulkan)
Solar Bay ÷ Solar Bay Extreme3.254.724.87

Three Benchmarks Available Only on Windows

Speed Way, Port Royal, and Wild Life cannot be compared with native, so we only checked that they run without errors in a Windows VM on a Mac, and looked at the scores.

BenchmarkAPIAny OS VMWindows PC (RTX 4090)
Speed WayDirectX 12 Ultimate3,361 pts / 33.61 FPS5,203 pts / 52.03 FPS
Port RoyalDirectX 128,463 pts / 39.18 FPS9,111 pts / 42.19 FPS
Wild LifeNo selection47,718 pts / 285.74 FPS82,394 pts / 493.38 FPS
  • Speed Way and Port Royal, the DirectX 12 benchmarks that use ray tracing, ran in the VM without errors and produced scores.
  • We could not confirm which API Wild Life used in the VM.

Speed Way

Speed Way result screen in 3DMark for Windows inside the Any OS VM
Any OS VM (DirectX 12): 3,361 pts, average 33.61 FPS
Speed Way result screen in 3DMark on the Windows PC
Windows PC (RTX 4090, DirectX 12): 5,203 pts, average 52.03 FPS

Port Royal

Port Royal result screen in 3DMark for Windows inside the Any OS VM
Any OS VM (DirectX 12): 8,463 pts, average 39.18 FPS
Port Royal result screen in 3DMark on the Windows PC
Windows PC (RTX 4090, DirectX 12): 9,111 pts, average 42.19 FPS

Wild Life

Wild Life result screen in 3DMark for Windows inside the Any OS VM
Any OS VM (no API selection): 47,718 pts, average 285.74 FPS
Wild Life result screen in 3DMark on the Windows PC
Windows PC (RTX 4090): 82,394 pts, average 493.38 FPS

Caveats When Reading These Results

  • 3DMark for Mac and 3DMark for Windows are separate programs with different versions, so the VM ÷ native value cannot be read purely as virtualization cost.
  • A difference of a few percent may be measurement variance.
  • VM numbers are for 4K full screen, and scores change when the output resolution changes.
  • The Windows PC (RTX 4090) differs in OS, GPU, and display conditions, so we do not use it for rankings or head-to-head comparisons.
  • Benchmark results do not guarantee compatibility or performance in individual games.
  • These results come from one Mac (Apple M5 Max), so the ratios may differ on other chips.

Summary

  • In 4 of the 5 benchmarks we compared, the Any OS VM reached about 90% of native or more: Solar Bay 129.9%, Steel Nomad Light 136.3%, Wild Life Extreme 92.7%, and Solar Bay Extreme 89.3%.
  • The Any OS VM on a Mac performs between the NVIDIA RTX 4060 Ti and 4070, the level of a mid-range graphics card.
  • All 5 DirectX 12 benchmarks ran in the VM without errors and produced scores. With Any OS, you can run DirectX 12 games on a Mac.

See all posts